Rivka's Refuge; 1st Assessment of the Complete article
This expanded article is ambitious, heartfelt, and deeply personal. It weaves together spiritual guidance, contemporary political commentary, and a call to action within the framework of Jewish tradition.
Strong, Clear Message of Hope: The author's note clearly states the two main points: optimism in the face of rising antisemitism and advocacy for sexual education reforms. This clarity helps guide the reader.Deeply Rooted in Jewish Tradition: The constant references to the Imahot (matriarchs), Mitzvot (commandments), Midrash, Pirkei Avos, Yeshayahu HaNavi, and various rabbinic teachings provide a solid spiritual and ethical foundation for all arguments.Passionate and Personal Voice: The article feels authentic and heartfelt. The author's personal experiences (preschool well project, Rabbi Breitowitz advice) and emotional reactions ("gut punch," "disheartening") make the piece relatable and impactful.Timely and Relevant: Addressing rising antisemitism, specific political outcomes, and controversies involving public figures immediately makes the article relevant to current events and pressing concerns.Call to Action for Women: The emphasis on the merit of righteous women and the specific Mitzvot (Nidah, Challah, Shabbos candles) provides a clear and empowering path forward for Jewish women.The "Leading with Kindness; Winning with Gratitude" section is excellent: As previously discussed, this section is well-structured, makes compelling arguments, and effectively connects ancient wisdom to modern challenges.
"Please recognize that the two main points are a message of optimism and hope in light of rising antisemitism and to advocate for reforms with regard to sexual education for frum girls in the Bais Yaakov system as I outline in the section titled "Nidah."" This is very clear and direct, which is good. However, the mention of "sexual education for frum girls" right at the beginning might be jarring for some readers who expect a broader message of hope before diving into specific reforms. You could consider a slightly softer phrasing, e.g., "and to advocate for enhanced education and support for frum girls in the Bais Yaakov system, particularly regarding personal purity and relationships, as I outline in the section titled 'Nidah.'" This still conveys the intent but perhaps prepares the reader more gently.
Flow of Political Commentary: The transition from the inspiring stories of the Imahot and the childhood well project to "two ominous events: an alarming electoral outcome and the meteoric rise of an avowed Neo-Nazi and Stalinist" is quite sudden.Suggestion: Consider a very brief bridge sentence or two that acknowledges the shift from spiritual inspiration to contemporary challenges. Something like, "While these eternal lessons offer profound comfort and guidance, the modern world presents its own stark realities that demand our attention and a response rooted in these very values." This helps the reader navigate the abrupt shift in tone and subject matter.
Specificity of Political Claims: "On Tuesday, November 4th, Zohran Mamdani, an alleged communist who appears to also be a Jihad apologist, was elected mayor of NYC..." This statement contains two factual inaccuracies that could undermine the article's credibility for some readers:Date: The US general election is always the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November. November 4th was a Friday in 2022, and Mamdani was elected to theNew York State Assembly (representing Astoria, Queens), not asMayor of NYC . Eric Adams was elected Mayor in 2021."Alleged communist who appears to also be a Jihad apologist": While Mamdani is a self-described democratic socialist and has taken controversial stances on Israel, labeling him an "alleged communist who appears to also be a Jihad apologist" is a strong accusation that could be seen as defaming and might require extremely robust sourcing to avoid being dismissed as partisan rhetoric. It's crucial for such specific accusations to be factually unassailable if you want to maintain broad credibility, especially when discussing public figures.
Recommendation: Given the potential for factual inaccuracies and strong accusations, you might consider either:Removing the specific name and office: Focus on thesentiment ortype of politician, e.g., "Last week, we witnessed alarming electoral outcomes where candidates with deeply troubling anti-Israel stances were elected in key metropolitan areas." This makes the point without risking factual errors or accusations of defamation.Verifying all facts and softening language: If you must keep the name, ensure the election details (date, office) are 100% correct, and consider rephrasing the "communist" and "Jihad apologist" claims to reflect publicly available, well-sourced information, rather than "alleged" or "appears to be." For example, you could focus on specific policies or statements he has made that you find problematic, rather than broad labels.
"A few short months ago, Charlie Kirk, צדיק אומות העולם and a great defender of the Jewish people, was tragically taken from us." Charlie Kirk is still alive and actively running Turning Point USA. This is a significant factual error.Recommendation: Thismust be corrected. If you intended to refer to someone else, please specify. If not, this section needs to be removed or rephrased completely. Factual errors of this magnitude can severely damage the credibility of an otherwise well-argued piece.
"What is especially painful, is that it is Jewish people who are leading the charge towards our destruction; Bernie Sanders, Dave Smith and Hannah Einbinder to name a few." This is a very strong and accusatory statement against specific individuals. While you are free to express your opinion on their political actions, attributing "leading the charge towards our destruction" to specific Jewish individuals is highly inflammatory and potentially defamatory, especially without specific, clear evidence presented within the article itself directly linking them to such an intent or outcome. Recommendation: Rephrase to focus on theiractions orstances that you find problematic, rather than making broad accusations about their intent or "leading the charge towards destruction." For example, "It is disheartening when prominent Jewish figures like Bernie Sanders, Dave Smith, and Hannah Einbinder take stances that, in our view, inadvertently undermine Jewish security or support movements hostile to Israel." This expresses your concern without making a potentially libelous accusation.
"There is a strong possibility that the liberal Jewish voting block might have been what tipped the scales for a candidate who refused to condemn the phrase 'Globalize the Intifada.'" This is a conjecture. While you can express concern about voting patterns, framing it as a "strong possibility" without presenting data or analysis within the article could be seen as an unsubstantiated claim.Recommendation: Keep it as a concern, but perhaps soften the phrasing or frame it as a question for reflection rather than a near-certainty: "The alignment of some liberal Jewish voters with candidates who refuse to condemn phrases like 'Globalize the Intifada' raises serious questions about the implications for our community."
"This betrayal leads us to question if our fellow אידען (Jews), people we are commanded to love as our own flesh, can still be considered a part of כלל ישראל." This is a deeply personal and painful question, and it's valid for you to raise it. It reflects a real struggle within the community.
The improvements made here are great. The flow into the Kevin Roberts section is much smoother.
Nidah Section: "The Midrash itself does not explicitly state that the cloud over Sarah's tent was specifically in the merit of the mitzvah of niddah. Interpretations connecting the cloud to specific mitzvot, like niddah, are often derived from later commentaries and teachings that explore the spiritual symbolism of these miracles." This is a good, scholarly clarification."I want to take this opportunity to point out the need for חיזוק with regard to קדושה and marriage in the Jewish community. There is an urgent need for reflection and reevaluation on how puberty, intimacy, and sexuality are taught to teenagers and young women. It's essential that these topics are introduced well before marriage, allowing young women to make informed decisions about their future partners. The current system, where education often occurs too late, needs reform. כלה teachers should meet high standards, with proper certification and oversight, ensuring they can address both biological and philosophical questions. Encouraging diverse perspectives and open dialogue is vital. Initiatives like those by the Eden Center and educational programs involving mothers are steps in the right direction. These efforts should be expanded to ensure comprehensive and accurate education for all. I share more about this topic including links to learn about books, programs and initiatives that are doing tremendous and important work on this topic in my article 'Ohel Sarah.'" This section clearly outlines your advocacy point. It's articulate and passionate. Suggestion: Ensure that the tone remains respectful and constructive when discussing reforms, which it largely does. The focus on "informed decisions" and "comprehensive and accurate education" is positive.
Challah Section: "I want to thank Tsipora Prince Agbodjan, from the shul located at Azza Street 24, for organizing a moving Challa Bake and communal Hafrashas Challa on Wednesday, November 5th, as part of the Shabbos project." Factual Check: As noted before, November 5th was a Sunday in 2023. You need to verify the date of this event.Recommendation: Correct the date.
Challah Recipe: Including a personal recipe is charming and adds a very personal, practical touch to the spiritual theme. It makes the abstract more tangible."Be careful - in Eretz Yisroel it is a חיוב דאורייתא to be מפריש חלה so it is very serious if you forget to do the הפרשה." This is a good and important halachic clarification.
Nerot Shabbat Section: "It is a greater חילול ה when Jewish people in NY do not believe that Hashem who created the world in 6 days and rested on the 7th than when they believe that a 'democratic' socialist is a worthy candidate to lead the premiere metropolis in the free world." This is a very strong theological and political statement. It effectively links faith and political choice. However, as noted before, the claim about "democratic socialist... to lead the premiere metropolis" should be fact-checked in the context of Mamdani's actual elected position (State Assembly, not Mayor). The sentiment about the perceived danger is clear, but precision about the office is important.Recommendation: If you keep the political reference, ensure its factual accuracy regarding the office.
"I am cognizant of the timing of all these troubling developments in government and media - the week that all these tragedies befell us, was the same week as the Shabbos project. A Shabbos once a year that אידען recommit themselves to the light of Shabbos." This connection of timing adds a poignant, almost mystical dimension to the events."If all the female 'Rabbis' who campaigned for Mamdani would light Shabbos candles this Friday night, that could bring Moshaich." This is a very pointed and controversial statement.Nuance: The phrase "female 'Rabbis'" itself carries a specific theological stance. Directly linking their political actions to withholding Mashiach through not lighting candles might be seen as highly judgmental and divisive, particularly within a piece aiming for unity and hope. While you are free to express your beliefs, consider the potential alienation of readers who might agree with your broader message but disagree with this specific theological-political judgment.Recommendation: You might want to soften this or rephrase it to focus on thepower ofall Jewish women to bring Mashiach through Mitzvot, rather than singling out a specific group for their political actions. For example, "Imagine the transformative power if all Jewish women, regardless of their political affiliations, would unite in the sanctity of Shabbos candle lighting; our sages teach us this could hasten the coming of Mashiach." This still conveys the spiritual power without the potentially alienating political jab.
The Candle Lighting Song: A beautiful and inspiring way to conclude, reinforcing the theme of hope, unity, and the power of Jewish women's Mitzvot.
"1. Purdue Pharma, Texas Children's Hospital and United Healthcare. It has been documented that Purdue Pharma faced accusations of bribery and undue influence in order to get Americans addicted to OxyContin." Accuracy Check: The statement "It has been documented that Purdue Pharma faced accusations of bribery and undue influence in order to get Americans addicted to OxyContin" is largely accurate in terms of public record, court cases, and settlements.
"2. Texas Children's Hospital at Baylour College of Medicine were exposed by Dr. Ethan Haim to be secretly providing gender transition healthcare to children ." Accuracy Check: This is a highly publicized and controversial claim. Dr. Haim is indeed a prominent whistleblower in this regard. The word "secretly" is appropriate here, as his claims revolved around the program continuing despite public statements otherwise.
"3. Dr. Elizabeth Potter, a physician who specializes in post-cancer reconstruction surgery, went viral when she shared her battle against the Insurance industry to ensure access to patients who need this specialized kind of care." Accuracy Check: This also aligns with publicized accounts.
"4. I want to make it abundantly clear that what Louige Mangione did is evil and has no justification." Accuracy Check: The name should beLuigi Mangione . This needs to be corrected. The statement about his act being evil is a moral judgment and clearly stated as such, which is fine.
Final Assessment:
תגובות
הוסף רשומת תגובה